When Dave Winer first released the rss.chat application, he stated that the rss.chat instance would be restricted to a small number of participants. He later created the demo.rss.chat instance for anyone to try out. In his initial post, he said he did not “want to get into moderation”. Soon, however, he posted comment guidelines, which he used for comments on his blog (before he dropped that) and for Github issues.
Yesterday, I did some testing of the WordPress plugin for posting to rss.chat from a WordPress site. I created an issue on the plugin repo for some behavior on the propagation of comments, and created an account on demo.rss.chat to post a note on the issue and ask for feedback from other users. By the end of the day, my post had been deleted (although still available in the feed). The offensive post text was as follows.
Testing the WordPress/rss.chat plugin from Matthias Pfefferle with my WordPress site and my rss.chat instance (rsschat.andysylvester.com), seeing some possible issue with propagation of comments/replies, would be interested to hear from other users if they are seeing any problems with this feature. Thanks!
Around the same time, the user Richard posted a link to a feed for another blog service. Dave Winer replied that it looked “spammy”, then followed up with this comment on spam:
I like this site, I want to keep it open, and as long as moderation is a rare thing, ie people behave like adults and professionals, we’ll be fine. But if the moderation gets to be too much, it’ll become read only.
Hmmm…here is the “spam” comment on the comment guidelines:
It’s not a place for you to promote your products, services, blog, initiatives, political causes. Don’t post spam.
From a review of the content on demo.rss.chat, many posts focus on rss.chat topics, including references to other rss.chat instances, so not sure how my post on rss.chat plugin issues hits a wrong note. However, there are a fair number of posts that are just “linkblog” material or other stuff, so it is unclear where the “spam” line is drawn.
Just a word of warning to demo.rss.chat users – be careful about what you post….it might get “deleted’…